These two positions are irreconcilable. ERO-026-0301 says water infrastructure must remain publicly owned. ERO-026-0302 states that municipalities must approve non-municipal water infrastructure, potentially privately owned and operated, on demand once prescribed criteria are met. A government that prohibits private ownership in one part of its water policy framework while mandating municipal approval of private systems in another is not following a coherent policy direction. It is advancing the incremental privatization of water and wastewater service delivery, one subdivision at a time, under a framework designed to make each individual approval appear routine.
ORA submits this letter to both contact addresses, the Intergovernmental Relations and Partnerships Branch for ERO-026-0302 and the Local Government Policy Branch for ERO-026-0301, precisely because the government’s fragmented consultation structure has ensured that neither branch is required to evaluate what the other has posted. These two offices are on the same floor of the same building in the same Ministry. The contradiction between their respective proposals is invisible to the process that is supposed to catch it. ORA is placing it before both branches simultaneously so that it cannot be evaluated in the absence of the other half of the picture.
Blog
ERO-026-0304: Draft Projection Methodology Guideline (PMG), 2026 to Support Implementation of the Provincial Planning Statement, 2024 (Bill 98)
West Credit River Brook Trout – Photo by Steve Nokams
ORA submits comments on ERO-026-0304 as part of a coordinated response to the Bill 98 legislative package. ORA has submitted separately on ERO-026-0315 (April 24, 2026), ERO-026-0313, ERO-026-0300, and ERO-026-0301/0302 (all May 14, 2026).6,7,8,9 The Projection Methodology Guideline (PMG) is foundational to this package: the land quantum it produces is the primary input driving (ary Expansion (SABE) decisions in official plan updates across Ontario. A methodology that systematically omits environmental constraints from its land supply calculations will generate land need figures that are overstated, ecologically unjustified, and will provide a spurious quantitative basis for designating development onto natural heritage lands, floodplains, river corridors, and watershed recharge areas that cannot and should not be built upon.
ERO-026-0312: Proposed Changes to Support Standardizing of Parkland Requirements Under the Planning Act (Bill 98)
The Ontario Provincial Climate Change Impact Assessment (OCCIA 2023) documents increasing precipitation intensity, hydrological volatility, and flood frequency across Ontario.4 The Auditor General of Ontario’s 2022 report on urban flood risk documented billions of dollars in flood-related municipal infrastructure losses and found that existing floodplain mapping substantially underestimates actual flood risk in many communities.5 Flooding events in spring 2024 and spring 2026 across the Sudbury, Ottawa, and Lake Erie watersheds caused widespread municipal infrastructure damage and emergency costs. Municipalities that accept floodplain-adjacent land as parkland will inherit maintenance liability and public safety responsibility for lands that are demonstrably at increasing flood risk.
ORA submits that floodplain-adjacent lands, including valley lands and riparian corridors that fall within but near the boundary of identified hazard areas, should be explicitly ineligible for developer-identified parkland credit, not merely eligible on an undefined condition.
ERO-026-0313: Streamlining the Information and Material That Planning Authorities Can Require as Part of a Complete Application (Bill 98)
Beyond the environmental risk, this proposal represents a significant and troubling shift in where municipal planning authority in Ontario resides. Local municipal councillors, planners and Conservation Authorities (CAs) possess on-the-ground knowledge of their watersheds, floodplains, and natural heritage systems that no standardized provincial list can replicate. They know which river reaches flood unpredictably, which unclassified wetlands provide critical flood attenuation, and which development proposals require additional study because of conditions unique to the local landscape.
Removing municipalities’ legal authority to act on that knowledge, and substituting a provincial uniformity standard in its place, moves decision-making away from the communities that must live with the consequences of planning decisions and toward a provincial administration that is not accountable to local conditions. This is not an administrative convenience; it is a transfer of authority over local environmental risk from the local governments best positioned to understand it, to a provincial government that has demonstrated, through the volume and pace of these interconnected regulatory changes, that its priority is development speed rather than environmental stewardship.
ERO-026-0364: Proposed Amendment to Ontario Regulation 316/07 to Remove Selected Lands from Beekahncheekahmeeng Deebahncheekayweehn Eenahohnahnuhn in Support of Pikangikum First Nation
ORA’s support is grounded in two considerations. First, this proposal fulfills a provincial commitment made in 1968, more than fifty years ago, to increase the size of Pikangikum First Nation’s reserve. Pikangikum First Nation requested this addition by Band Council Resolution to address the community’s immediate housing and infrastructure needs. With a current on-reserve population of over 3,800 people, projected to reach up to 6,000 by 2038, and over 95% of the membership living on reserve, the need for additional land is both legitimate and urgent. Honouring this longstanding commitment is a matter of basic fairness and substantive reconciliation.
Second, ORA notes that Pikangikum First Nation has identified the 17-hectare parcel as a cultural waterway. ORA’s mission centers on the protection of river and waterway ecosystems as public trust assets sustaining ecological, cultural, and community well-being. The cultural waterway designation signals that these lands carry significance beyond their small geographic footprint within the broader 96,085-hectare park. ORA encourages Ontario and Canada to ensure that stewardship of these lands, once transferred, is guided by Pikangikum’s own knowledge of their cultural and ecological values, consistent with Pikangikum’s longstanding role as co-stewards of the “Keeping the Land” (Community-Based Land Use Plan), developed and approved jointly by Pikangikum and Ontario in 2006.
IESO: Long-Term 2 RFP Feedback – April 21, 2026
The IESO’s Hybrid Resource Portfolio Equivalency Assessment (August 2025) demonstrated that portfolios built from wind, solar, and battery storage can meet Ontario’s electricity needs with reliability approaching 99.9 percent load served in modelled scenarios, all the way out to 2050.
That finding should have clarified Ontario’s path forward. Instead, the Minister of Energy rejected that direction and directed the IESO to advance new hydropower procurement, stating that these competing technologies “are deemed not well-suited to competing against resources with shorter development timelines and lifespans… but are able to offer unique benefits to Ontario’s electricity system through resource diversification.” Unfortunately, the Minister did not identify or quantify these ‘unique benefits,’ nor demonstrate that they outweigh the higher cost, longer timelines, and increased risk associated with hydropower.
IESO: 2026 Annual Planning Outlook Feedback – April 21, 2026
Vermilion River – Our grandchildren’s future with water!
ORA’s central concern with the 2026 APO is the IESO’s continuing commitment to new-build hydroelectric generation: the 1 TWh annual imputed energy stream under the Long Lead-Time (LLT) Request for Proposals (RFP), Northern Hydro Program, 20- and 40-year contracts, environmental benefits, transmissions lines, ratepayer and taxpayer impacts, and the two proposed Nine Mile Rapids and Grand Rapids hydroelectric stations in the Moose River Basin. The subsections that follow set out, on the procurement record, why this commitment is incompatible with the IESO’s own ratepayer-protection mandate.
IESO: ORA Comments on Long Lead-Time RFP Engagement on April 23, 2026
The LLT RFP, as currently structured, does not protect Ontario rivers, ratepayers or taxpayers, and is not in the public interest. It creates a hydro-only energy stream, offers 40-year revenue certainty to proponents, advances long-lead water-dependent infrastructure with a 100-year lifespan, without visible integration of Ontario’s own climate science, and responds to industry pressure for greater investor protection while leaving the public to bear long-term environmental and financial risk.
Ontario does not need to sacrifice rivers to meet electricity needs. IESO’s own modelling shows that wind, solar and battery storage portfolios can meet future needs with very high reliability. The responsible course is to prioritize lower-impact, faster-deploying, scalable resources, protect existing rivers, and ensure that any long-term procurement is grounded in climate science, cumulative effects assessment, and transparent ratepayer accountability.
Ontario should not lock households, businesses, and future generations into decades of avoidable financial and environmental liability for a climate-vulnerable energy source when lower-impact, scalable, increasingly cost-effective, and climate-resilient alternatives already exist.
ERO-026-0315 — Consultation on Upper-Tier Official Plans, Secondary Plans, and Site- and Area-Specific Policies (Bill 98)
A Vermilion River Otter, By Al Oman
ERO-026-0315 is the latest in a series of rapid, interconnected changes to Ontario’s planning framework. Since 2018, successive amendments to the Planning Act have progressively weakened environmental protections, reduced public participation requirements, and concentrated approval authority in the Minister of Municipal Affairs and Housing.1 ERO-026-0315 continues this trajectory.
This erosion of planning oversight is compounded by the concurrent restructuring of Conservation Authorities. Ontario’s 36 watershed-based Conservation Authorities, each delineated according to the natural boundaries of local watershed systems, are being amalgamated into 9 regional bodies with vastly larger geographic territories.
IESO: Long Lead-Time RFP – March 26, 2026
Big Falls – Victory – stopped a proposed hydroelectric project on a sacred site!
This is a fundamental failure of open and transparent dialogue before municipal and Indigenous consent is awarded. For any hydroelectric development, the full hydraulic footprint, including the headpond, inundation zone, drawdown range, and affected upstream and downstream wetland and river reaches, constitutes the project’s actual physical and ecological footprint. Limiting the project site definition to the dam structure and immediate generating works conceals the true scope of the project from the municipality, Indigenous communities, and the public before the Municipal Support Resolution or Evidence of Indigenous Support is received.
ORA’s position, consistent with our March 2026 submission, is that proponents must fully disclose the complete hydraulic footprint to the municipality and Indigenous communities. This information is required for:
- Meaningful environmental considerations and impact assessment
- Number and extent of all project sites required
- Free, prior, and informed consent processes with affected First Nations and Métis communities
- Accurate assessment of land tenure, Crown resource conflicts, and access rights
- Informed public participation