Blog

Photo by Linda HeronPhoto Credit

Category Archives: Environmental Reports

ORA comments on the Crawford Nickel Project’s Impact Statement (Ref No. 83857)

While the Crawford Nickel Project represents a pivotal opportunity for economic growth and partnership with Indigenous communities, it also carries profound environmental responsibilities for these same communities.  Canada Nickel Company touts its core principles embedded in its operations and commits to genuine partnerships with Indigenous peoples. However, the long-term health of freshwater ecosystems and the surrounding environment that they rely on must remain paramount in its priorities.

ORA urges the adoption of the most advanced, rigorous, and adaptive environmental protections to ensure that today’s progress does not come at the expense of tomorrow’s ecosystems. The decisions we make now will echo for generations. Let us ensure that they are rooted in sustainability, accountability, and respect for the land and water that sustain us all.

Continue reading


Embro Dam Removal Environmental Report – ORA Support

ORA offers our strong support for your recommendation to proceed with the implementation of Alternative 4, to remove the dam and construct a naturalized channel with linked offline wetland habitat, as described in Section 7 of the Embro Dam Class Environmental Assessment.

As mentioned in our 9 February 2023 comments, we prefer a wetland, versus a pond construction, primarily because a shallow pond can be a key source of solar warming and greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions; whereas, a wetland provides a more diverse environment, where the shade provided by appropriate native plants such as lily pads, bulrushes, and shrubs can help reduce solar warming and create a wildlife habitat. This is a crucial decision, as sensitive coldwater Brook Trout populations require temperatures no greater than 19 to 20°C for any sustained period of time, and below 9°C are required for a successful spawn.

Whether creating a wetland/s or a pond, we are very much in support of the Upper Thames Conservation Authority’s decision to remove Embro Dam to create a natural channel and habitat.

Continue reading


EBR Application for Investigation of Town of Erin – Proposed Erin Wastewater Treatment Plant – Joint

West Credit River Brook Trout. Photo by Steve Noakes.

The Belfountain Community and Planning Organization and Linda Heron are filing an Application for Investigation of the Corporation of the Town of Erin, under Part V, of the Environmental Bill of Rights, 1993. We are very concerned that the Town is moving forward to the construction phase of the Project when it has not yet fulfilled key commitments it made in its Town of Erin Urban Centre Wastewater Servicing Class Environmental Study Report.  The Ministry will investigate whether the Town contravened or violated Section 38 of the Environmental Assessment Act. 

Please click on this Google Drive link to view or download the Application for Investigation and Appendix A.  Continue reading


Media Release: Concerns over Brook Trout in the West Credit River

Brook trout spawning in a coldwater stream.  Film by Steve Noakes

Articles:
Groups concerned about Erin’s proposed plant effect on coldwater fish, by Keegan Kozolanka
Ontario Rivers Alliance says town has ‘dismissed’ plans to protect Credit River brook trout from Erin wastewater plant, by Alexandra Heck

The Town of Erin (Erin) is in the design phase of a new sewage treatment plant, and the Ontario Rivers Alliance (ORA) is concerned that the sewage plant effluent will endanger some of the most productive and highly valued brook trout populations in the West Credit River. Continue reading


Town of Erin Wastewater Treatment Plant – Concerns over Brook Trout and Fish Habitat on the West Credit River

Finally, the West Credit River is a headwaters tributary of the Credit River and is considered the crown jewel of coldwater brook trout fisheries in Ontario. This fishery significantly adds to the economic and social fabric of the province, with Ontario fisheries contributing a total of approximately $2.5 billion annually to the provincial economy.  MNRF’s own documents predict that climate change will reduce the number of watersheds in Ontario with brook trout by 50% by 2050.

Continue reading


Calabogie Generating Station Redevelopment Project – Notice of Completion

The fact that Lake Sturgeon and American Eel no longer exists in this section of the Madawaska River, is all the more reason that OPG should make every effort to rehabilitate these populations and include effective fish passage for these and other fish species at this facility.  OPG is a provincial entity and as such should set the example as a beacon for responsible and sustainable hydroelectric facilities and operations in Ontario.

Continue reading


Calabogie Generating Station Redevelopment – Madawaska River

Peaking operations, with the variable flow discharge and ramping patterns, the rate and frequency of water level changes, and the amount of time the station is at its maximum discharge level, can all have a significant impact on the degree of channel and bank erosion.

Continue reading


Riverside Dam Class Environmental Assessment – Speed River

Drought conditions could place additional stress on riverine ecosystems, while more extreme rainfall will heighten the risk of dam failures (18 dams were breached in a South Carolina flood in October of 2015) with rapid release of high volumes of water.  There have also been recent dam failures right here in Ontario – the Gorrie Dam failure last year in Wingham was the most recent, putting more than 150 property owners at risk.

Continue reading


10 Ontario Rivers Protected from 19 Hydroelectric Projects

Wabagishik Rapids – Vermilion River

Update: In the end, ORA and our membership stopped 24 projects on 12 rivers.

MEDIA RELEASE:  For Immediate Release:  13 July 2016

10 Ontario Rivers Protected from 19 Hydroelectric Projects

SUDBURY:  The Ontario Rivers Alliance (ORA) is celebrating a major victory in the protection of 10 Ontario rivers that have been under threat from 19 proposed hydroelectric projects.   Actions taken by the ORA and its members have led to what was considered to be impossible – the termination of 19 Feed-in-Tariff (FIT) Contracts.

In 2011, ORA came into being to address a rash of 87 proposed hydroelectric proposals initiated under the Green Energy Act.  The offer of generous incentives to produce power during peak demand hours had proponents rushing to claim access to falls and rapids on rivers all across the province.  The number of proposals to actually receive FIT Contracts was soon reduced to 41, and of those, Xeneca Power Development Inc. had secured 19 contracts for projects involving 23 Crown sites on 10 Ontario rivers. Continue reading


Wabagishik Rapids Generating Station – Minister’s Decision on Part II Order Request

Wabagishik Rapids, Vermilion River - Photo by Aleta Karstad

Wabagishik Rapids, Vermilion River – Photo by Aleta Karstad

It was very surprising and disappointing to read your decision letter; however, it was somewhat understandable when the Minister’s decision was based upon inaccurate and unsupported responses contained within the Ministry Review (Review) document, Xeneca Power Development Inc.’s (Xeneca) correspondence, and the Environmental Report (ER). Continue reading