Blog

Photo by Linda HeronPhoto Credit

Category Archives: Municipal

ERO-026-0300: Proposed Planning Act, City of Toronto Act, 2006, Building Code Act, 1992 and Municipal Act, 2001 Changes (Schedules 1, 2 and 7 of Bill 98, the Building Homes and Improving Transportation Infrastructure Act, 2026)

ORA’s concern is direct and practical. MZOs have been used in Ontario to authorize development on or adjacent to sensitive wetlands, floodplains, and river corridors, in some cases over the objections of CAs and local municipalities. The notice requirement has been the only mechanism by which organizations like ORA can identify when a proposed MZO amendment affects a river system, place concerns on the public record, and seek to influence the Minister’s decision before it is made. Removing notice does not constrain the use of MZOs; it makes their use invisible until it is too late. For watershed and river protection purposes, an MZO amendment process with no public notice is a process with no meaningful public participation at all.

ORA submits that notice requirements for MZO amendments and revocations must be retained without qualification. If the government’s concern is administrative efficiency, notice can be provided through streamlined electronic means with a fixed and short comment window. Removing public notice entirely is not a proportionate or defensible administrative reform.

Continue reading →


ERO-026-0301 and ERO-026-0302: Proposed Amendments to the Municipal Act, 2001 and the Safe Drinking Water Act, 2002 Respecting Communal Drinking Water and Wastewater System Municipal Consent Requirements (Schedule 4 of Bill 98, the Building Homes and Improving Transportation Infrastructure Act, 2026)

These two positions are irreconcilable. ERO-026-0301 says water infrastructure must remain publicly owned. ERO-026-0302 states that municipalities must approve non-municipal water infrastructure, potentially privately owned and operated, on demand once prescribed criteria are met. A government that prohibits private ownership in one part of its water policy framework while mandating municipal approval of private systems in another is not following a coherent policy direction. It is advancing the incremental privatization of water and wastewater service delivery, one subdivision at a time, under a framework designed to make each individual approval appear routine.

ORA submits this letter to both contact addresses, the Intergovernmental Relations and Partnerships Branch for ERO-026-0302 and the Local Government Policy Branch for ERO-026-0301, precisely because the government’s fragmented consultation structure has ensured that neither branch is required to evaluate what the other has posted. These two offices are on the same floor of the same building in the same Ministry. The contradiction between their respective proposals is invisible to the process that is supposed to catch it. ORA is placing it before both branches simultaneously so that it cannot be evaluated in the absence of the other half of the picture.

Continue reading →


ERO-019-7891: New regulation to focus municipal environmental assessment

Allan’s Dam & Allan’s Dam Bridge, Guelph, Speed River.

Ontario does not need faster approvals at the expense of environmental protection, public accountability, and long-term resilience. The MCEA, while imperfect, remains a defensible and improvable planning framework. The proposed MPAP represents a significant regression—one that would set environmental governance, public participation, and infrastructure accountability back by decades.

ORA urges the Ministry to abandon this proposal and work collaboratively to strengthen, rather than dismantle, Ontario’s environmental assessment system.

Continue reading →


Section 16 Order Request: Allan’s Dam, Spillway and Sluiceway, City of Guelph, Speed River

Infrasture stacked on top of and surrounding Allans Dam and Spillway.

The handling and outcome of the Macdonell and Allan’s Structures MCEA constitute a serious procedural failure that infringes on the constitutionally protected Aboriginal and treaty rights of the Six Nations of the Grand River, the Mississaugas of the Credit First Nation, and the Haudenosaunee Confederacy. Throughout the five-year MCEA process, the City withheld essential information—including the dam’s true age (155 years), the absence of any structural or subsurface assessment, the deteriorated condition of the spillway, and the 2018 OSIM recommendation for a LRIA-compliant Dam Safety Review. None of this was disclosed to Indigenous rights holders, despite the project’s direct implications for the Speed River, its fish, habitat, water quality, and flood risk.

Continue reading →


ERO-025-1097 – Proposed Changes to the Planning Act

Photo by Steven Noakes

The ORA is strongly opposed to the proposed amendments to the Planning Act in Schedule 10 of Bill 60, Fighting Delays, Building Faster Act, 2025. These changes further erode Ontario’s already weakened land-use planning system, remove core environmental and climate safeguards, undermine public and Indigenous rights, and consolidate extraordinary discretionary powers in the hands of the Minister.

These proposals follow a multi-year trend of dismantling core environmental protections, accelerating sprawl, and sidelining evidence-based planning in favour of political expediency. Schedule 10 is not a “streamlining” measure—it is a structural restructuring of Ontario’s planning regime at the direct expense of watershed health, climate resilience, and public accountability.

ORA urges the Province to withdraw Schedule 10 in its entirety.

Continue reading →


Laurentian River–A Highly Valued Aquifer at Risk in High Park, Toronto

The Ministry of the Environment, Conservation and Parks confirms that this location lies within a Highly Vulnerable Aquifer (HVA)—one of the most sensitive groundwater zones recognized under Ontario’s source protection framework. HVAs are explicitly protected because disturbance, dewatering, excavation, and large-scale impermeable development can alter groundwater flow, create contamination pathways, and permanently destabilize subsurface hydrology.

The developer’s own geotechnical consultants repeated multiple times that “further investigation is required” regarding groundwater conditions. When a proponent cannot establish foundational geotechnical certainty on an HVA, the City must halt the process rather than gamble with groundwater systems that sustain High Park, its creeks, wetlands, and ecological communities.

Continue reading →


ORA & VRS: Delegation to Sudbury Planning Committee – Exclude new hydroelectric in its Official Plan

Wabagishik Rapids, Vermilion River

Hydropower has been aggressively greenwashed for decades, despite well-documented, significant, and ongoing adverse environmental effects from its impoundments and peaking operations.

The negative environmental effects of hydro dams, reservoirs, and operating strategies can be extensive, affecting many kilometres upstream and downstream of the dam. That series of five cascading projects, six counting Vale’s Wabagishik Generating Station, would have been strung out for over 130 km of river, impacting from Capreol, all the way out to where it joins the Spanish River. It would have dramatically changed the Vermilion on many levels, stirring up contaminated sediment and impacting local residents who rely on the River for drinking water.

Proponents often claim hydro projects will last for 100 years, but there is a dark side to that.

Over the last three decades, a growing body of independent peer-reviewed research reports that hydroelectric reservoirs can be a significant and ongoing source of GHG emissions in boreal, temperate, and tropical regions. In fact, reservoir methane emissions can rival or exceed those coming from natural gas facilities over a 20-year horizon (e.g., DelSontro et al., 2018; Beaulieu et al, 2020; Scherer & Pfister, 2016).

Continue reading →


Speed River: Macdonell and Allan’s Structures Municipal Class Environmental Assessment

Allan’s Dam & Allan’s Dam Bridge, Guelph, Speed River.

Our own research revealed that Allan’s Dam is a legacy mill dam, originally constructed in the 1830s to power Allan’s Mill—one of Guelph’s founding industrial sites. Sometime later, the structure was adapted for hydroelectric generation, likely in the early to mid-20th century. It is our understanding that this facility has not generated electricity for several decades and now functions only as an aging dam, concrete spillway and sluiceway, impounding a shallow headpond on the Speed River. It appears that this infrastructure no longer serves any useful purpose while continuing to fragment habitat, degrade water quality, and emit copious amounts of carbon, methane, and nitrous oxide into the atmosphere.

Continue reading →


Ontario Auditor General’s Report on Non-Municipal Drinking Water – CELA, Joint

As we near the 25th anniversary of the deadly drinking water tragedy in Walkerton, Ont., we are calling on the government to reaffirm Ontario’s commitment to safe drinking water for all by implementing the Auditor General’s 17 recommendations in a meaningful, timely and transparent way.

In addition to these findings, the Auditor General cited concerns about transparency, rigor and timeliness in how MECP and MoH approach regulatory modernization. Of note was MECPs incomplete feasibility assessment regarding protecting the source water of non-municipal systems – a critically important protection that is only afforded to Ontarians who rely on drinking water systems owned and operated by municipalities.

Continue reading →


ERO-019-8369 – Proposed Bill 185, Cutting Red Tape to Build More Homes Act, 2024

Vermilion River – Our grandchildren’s future with water!

The ORA is strongly opposed to the proposal to remove the public’s appeal rights for the adoption or amendment of Official Plans and Zoning By-Laws to the Ontario Land Tribunal (OLT). These amendments are unfair as they undermine the public’s right to appeal local land-use decisions and deny access to justice. The public’s right to appeal has been a long-standing feature of the Planning Act, and there is no persuasive evidence-based reason by this government to revoke this important right. It is consequential when a municipality approves a project that would be environmentally damaging to a property owner or may cause public health issues to the local community, the public would no longer be able to challenge the municipality’s decision at the OLT.

Continue reading →