Blog

Photo by Linda HeronPhoto Credit

Category Archives: Crown Land Use Policy

ERO-026-0696: Changes to Streamline Natural Resource Permits: Removal of Forest Resources (Trees) for Non-Forestry Activities Proposed addition of the Environmental Protection Act, 1990 to the listed Acts

Vermilion River – Our grandchildren’s future with water!

ORA is deeply concerned about where these changes lead when they are taken together. The streamlining of environmental assessment, the spread of permit-by-rule, and the government’s direction to move MNR away from its strengths in protecting public land would leave Ontario’s forests and rivers, and the rich social and economic values they hold, to be decided project by project by proponents whose bottom line is profit. Together, these changes would roll back more than a century of public stewardship and place the health and safety of communities at dire risk.

Continue reading →


ERO-026-0364: Proposed Amendment to Ontario Regulation 316/07 to Remove Selected Lands from Beekahncheekahmeeng Deebahncheekayweehn Eenahohnahnuhn in Support of Pikangikum First Nation

ORA’s support is grounded in two considerations. First, this proposal fulfills a provincial commitment made in 1968, more than fifty years ago, to increase the size of Pikangikum First Nation’s reserve. Pikangikum First Nation requested this addition by Band Council Resolution to address the community’s immediate housing and infrastructure needs. With a current on-reserve population of over 3,800 people, projected to reach up to 6,000 by 2038, and over 95% of the membership living on reserve, the need for additional land is both legitimate and urgent. Honouring this longstanding commitment is a matter of basic fairness and substantive reconciliation.

Second, ORA notes that Pikangikum First Nation has identified the 17-hectare parcel as a cultural waterway. ORA’s mission centers on the protection of river and waterway ecosystems as public trust assets sustaining ecological, cultural, and community well-being. The cultural waterway designation signals that these lands carry significance beyond their small geographic footprint within the broader 96,085-hectare park. ORA encourages Ontario and Canada to ensure that stewardship of these lands, once transferred, is guided by Pikangikum’s own knowledge of their cultural and ecological values, consistent with Pikangikum’s longstanding role as co-stewards of the “Keeping the Land” (Community-Based Land Use Plan), developed and approved jointly by Pikangikum and Ontario in 2006.

Continue reading →


IESO: ORA Comments on Long Lead-Time RFP Engagement on April 23, 2026

The LLT RFP, as currently structured, does not protect Ontario rivers, ratepayers or taxpayers, and is not in the public interest. It creates a hydro-only energy stream, offers 40-year revenue certainty to proponents, advances long-lead water-dependent infrastructure with a 100-year lifespan, without visible integration of Ontario’s own climate science, and responds to industry pressure for greater investor protection while leaving the public to bear long-term environmental and financial risk.

Ontario does not need to sacrifice rivers to meet electricity needs. IESO’s own modelling shows that wind, solar and battery storage portfolios can meet future needs with very high reliability. The responsible course is to prioritize lower-impact, faster-deploying, scalable resources, protect existing rivers, and ensure that any long-term procurement is grounded in climate science, cumulative effects assessment, and transparent ratepayer accountability.

Ontario should not lock households, businesses, and future generations into decades of avoidable financial and environmental liability for a climate-vulnerable energy source when lower-impact, scalable, increasingly cost-effective, and climate-resilient alternatives already exist.

Continue reading →


IESO: Long Lead-Time RFP – March 26, 2026

Big Falls – Victory – stopped a proposed hydroelectric project on a sacred site!

This is a fundamental failure of open and transparent dialogue before municipal and Indigenous consent is awarded. For any hydroelectric development, the full hydraulic footprint, including the headpond, inundation zone, drawdown range, and affected upstream and downstream wetland and river reaches, constitutes the project’s actual physical and ecological footprint. Limiting the project site definition to the dam structure and immediate generating works conceals the true scope of the project from the municipality, Indigenous communities, and the public before the Municipal Support Resolution or Evidence of Indigenous Support is received.

ORA’s position, consistent with our March 2026 submission, is that proponents must fully disclose the complete hydraulic footprint to the municipality and Indigenous communities. This information is required for:

  • Meaningful environmental considerations and impact assessment
  • Number and extent of all project sites required
  • Free, prior, and informed consent processes with affected First Nations and Métis communities
  • Accurate assessment of land tenure, Crown resource conflicts, and access rights
  • Informed public participation

Continue reading →


IESO: Long Lead-Time RFP – February 26, 2026

Lake Sturgeon stranded in a hydroelectric facility’s overflow channel.

In the February 26 Long Lead-Time (LLT) engagement, IESO staff confirmed that proponents are not required to include the flooded area or headpond in their LLT application and that inundation details can be left to the environmental assessment stage. That approach might be administratively convenient, but it is not acceptable for water-based projects with 40-year contracts. The headpond and inundation zone are not minor details; they are often the largest part of a hydro facility’s footprint, which can spread over the riverbank, affecting wetlands, private property, municipal infrastructure, upstream creeks and tributaries, and the full extent of aquatic habitat that will be flooded or subject to fluctuating water levels. Many hectares of previously dry land can be flooded to make these projects work and are key to generating power on demand, especially on smaller rivers under 10 MW.

Continue reading →


IESO: Long Lead-Time RFP – January 28, 2026

Photo by Al Oman

ORA is increasingly concerned by the cumulative financial burden being placed on Ontario electricity ratepayers through IESO procurement and contract design choices. Across recent engagements, ratepayers have been positioned as the default risk absorber for:

  1. Retention and monetization of environmental attributes and clean energy claims funded through ratepayer-supported contracts, even where those attributes are later used to meet industrial or policy objectives.
  2. Stacking of multiple compensation mechanisms—energy payments, capacity payments, environmental attributes, and risk-mitigation provisions—for the same facility, without commensurate accountability for performance under real-world operating and climate conditions
  3. Long-term fixed-price contracts for resources whose performance is declining under climate change.
  4. Settlement mechanisms that compensate for non-delivery rather than enforcing performance discipline.
  5. Escalating system costs associated with transmission expansion, deliverability constraints, and congestion management.
  6. Stranded or underperforming assets locked into multi-decade contracts.
  7. Policy-driven procurement volumes that exceed demonstrated domestic reliability needs.

ORA is concerned that ratepayers are financing the assets and contracts that generate those credits, only to be told the credits are “extra value”. Concerned that environmental benefits and clean energy attributes are being treated as additive system value even where the underlying resource is energy-limited, intermittently unavailable, or unable to perform during system stress events. When ratepayers fund long-term contracts, absorb hydrologic risk, and also underwrite environmental attributes for the same facility, the result is cost stacking rather than value creation. This approach obscures true system costs and further weakens the link between public expenditure and actual climate or reliability outcomes. Environmental attributes should not be used to mask or compensate for poor operational performance or climate vulnerability.

Continue reading →


ERO-025-1145: Natural Resources Regulatory and Permit Reform Initiative: Proposing changes to the Renewable Energy on Crown Land policy

ERO-025-1145 does not represent prudent regulatory reform. It represents a deliberate policy choice to subordinate Ontario’s rivers, climate commitments, and public-interest safeguards to an unmandated “energy superpower” agenda built on outdated assumptions about hydropower. By ignoring Ontario’s own Climate Change Impact Assessment, greenwashing hydropower, downplaying methane emissions, dismissing cumulative effects, and failing to require decommissioning, fish passage, and financial security, the proposed amendments expose the Province to long-term ecological, legal, and financial risk.

Free-flowing rivers are among Ontario’s most valuable and climate-resilience assets. Once fragmented, flooded, or abandoned, they cannot be easily or cheaply restored. ORA urges the Ministry to withdraw these amendments, re-ground Crown land policy in contemporary science and Indigenous rights and reject the false premise that new hydropower—particularly under the 10-MW scale—is compatible with climate responsibility or watershed protection.

Continue reading →


ERO-025-1078: Natural Resources Regulatory and Permit Reform Initiative: Proposing changes to streamline certain approvals under the Public Lands Act

Photo by Mark Clement

This two-step approach shifts risk away from proponents and onto Ontario’s rivers, Indigenous Nations, and the public interest—at precisely the moment when climate change, flooding, and freshwater ecosystem decline demand stronger, not weaker, precaution. By exempting early disturbances, narrowing shore-land protections, and relying on registration rather than site-specific authorization, the Province is effectively pre-approving development pathways before their ecological and social consequences are understood.

Ontario’s rivers and Crown lands are not expendable staging grounds for an unexamined “energy superpower” agenda. They are public trust resources and critical climate-resilience infrastructure. ORA therefore urges the Ministry to withdraw ERO-025-1078, reassess it jointly with ERO-025-1145, and re-establish a regulatory framework grounded in contemporary freshwater science, Indigenous rights, and the precautionary principle.

Subsequent Ministry correspondence dated November 6, 2025, confirms that ERO-025-1145 and ERO-025-1078 form part of a single, coordinated initiative to streamline Crown land and in-water approvals, reinforcing ORA’s concern that these proposals must be assessed together for their cumulative ecological and governance impacts.

Continue reading →


ERO-025-1134: Natural Resources Regulatory and Permit Reform Initiative: Improving forest legislation, regulations, processes and forest management policy

ERO-025-1134 does not represent neutral modernization of forest policy. When combined with concurrent Crown land, Public Lands Act, and economic reforms, it forms part of a coordinated deregulation agenda that will predictably intensify pressure on Ontario’s rivers through expanded hydropower and associated infrastructure. Weakening forest oversight at a time of accelerating climate change, cumulative watershed stress, and public-safety risk is neither precautionary nor responsible. ORA urges the Province to halt this trajectory and restore a science-based, integrated approach to forest, land, and river stewardship that protects Ontario’s natural heritage for present and future generations.

Continue reading →


ORA Celebrates 10 years of Service to Ontario Rivers

A presentation made by the Chair of ORA:

A presentation made by the Chair at ORA’s 16 October 2021 Annual General Meeting:

Continue reading →