Blog

Photo by Linda HeronPhoto Credit

Category Archives: Species at Risk Act

ERO-026-0696: Changes to Streamline Natural Resource Permits: Removal of Forest Resources (Trees) for Non-Forestry Activities Proposed addition of the Environmental Protection Act, 1990 to the listed Acts

Vermilion River – Our grandchildren’s future with water!

ORA is deeply concerned about where these changes lead when they are taken together. The streamlining of environmental assessment, the spread of permit-by-rule, and the government’s direction to move MNR away from its strengths in protecting public land would leave Ontario’s forests and rivers, and the rich social and economic values they hold, to be decided project by project by proponents whose bottom line is profit. Together, these changes would roll back more than a century of public stewardship and place the health and safety of communities at dire risk.

Continue reading →


ERO 026-0539: Changes to Streamline Natural Resource Permits: Fish and Wildlife Modernization

“Blandings Turtle” by tcmurray74 is licensed under CC BY-NC 2.0

The changes would allow “mining and infrastructure projects to move forward faster and with greater certainty.”1 The tool MNR has chosen to deliver that speed is self-registration. A person registers with MNR to inform the ministry of what they intend to do, receives a confirmation, and proceeds. No ministry staff review the site. No conditions are written for that site. There is no oversight and no follow-up. The proposal describes no step at which MNR reviews or refuses a registration.

This is a total retreat from the Ministry of Natural Resources’ mandate and responsibility for “protecting and managing the province’s diverse natural resources to support Ontario’s economic prosperity, environmental sustainability, and quality of life for the people of Ontario.”2 Economic prosperity is one part of that mandate. Section 5 shows that it cannot be delivered by giving up the other two parts.

Continue reading →


Consultation on the Proposed Critical Habitat Protection Regulations made under section 59 of the Species at Risk Act-Joint

American Eel–Elvers

Ontario Nature, alongside our Nature Network of over 150 community-based groups, provincial and national partners, collectively strive to protect and restore nature for all species and future generations. Within Ontario, we represent over 130,000 members and supporters.

Earlier this year, the Government of Ontario officially repealed the Endangered Species Act, 2007, replacing it with the Species Conservation Act that was part of Bill 5, which passed in June 2025. The Species Conservation Act delists migratory birds and aquatic species, arguing protections were duplicative of federal legislation. This assertion ignores the tendency of the federal government to limit the scope of the Species at Risk Act to federal lands, as is the case with the proposed CHPR.

Continue reading →


ERO-026-0300: Proposed Planning Act, City of Toronto Act, 2006, Building Code Act, 1992 and Municipal Act, 2001 Changes (Schedules 1, 2 and 7 of Bill 98, the Building Homes and Improving Transportation Infrastructure Act, 2026)

ORA’s concern is direct and practical. MZOs have been used in Ontario to authorize development on or adjacent to sensitive wetlands, floodplains, and river corridors, in some cases over the objections of CAs and local municipalities. The notice requirement has been the only mechanism by which organizations like ORA can identify when a proposed MZO amendment affects a river system, place concerns on the public record, and seek to influence the Minister’s decision before it is made. Removing notice does not constrain the use of MZOs; it makes their use invisible until it is too late. For watershed and river protection purposes, an MZO amendment process with no public notice is a process with no meaningful public participation at all.

ORA submits that notice requirements for MZO amendments and revocations must be retained without qualification. If the government’s concern is administrative efficiency, notice can be provided through streamlined electronic means with a fixed and short comment window. Removing public notice entirely is not a proportionate or defensible administrative reform.

Continue reading →


ERO-026-0301 and ERO-026-0302: Proposed Amendments to the Municipal Act, 2001 and the Safe Drinking Water Act, 2002 Respecting Communal Drinking Water and Wastewater System Municipal Consent Requirements (Schedule 4 of Bill 98, the Building Homes and Improving Transportation Infrastructure Act, 2026)

These two positions are irreconcilable. ERO-026-0301 says water infrastructure must remain publicly owned. ERO-026-0302 states that municipalities must approve non-municipal water infrastructure, potentially privately owned and operated, on demand once prescribed criteria are met. A government that prohibits private ownership in one part of its water policy framework while mandating municipal approval of private systems in another is not following a coherent policy direction. It is advancing the incremental privatization of water and wastewater service delivery, one subdivision at a time, under a framework designed to make each individual approval appear routine.

ORA submits this letter to both contact addresses, the Intergovernmental Relations and Partnerships Branch for ERO-026-0302 and the Local Government Policy Branch for ERO-026-0301, precisely because the government’s fragmented consultation structure has ensured that neither branch is required to evaluate what the other has posted. These two offices are on the same floor of the same building in the same Ministry. The contradiction between their respective proposals is invisible to the process that is supposed to catch it. ORA is placing it before both branches simultaneously so that it cannot be evaluated in the absence of the other half of the picture.

Continue reading →


ERO-019-8972 – Protected Area Expansions for Missinaibi Provincial Park and Woodland Caribou Provincial Park

Thunderhouse Falls, Missinaibi River – 1997

These additions, 490 hectares for Missinaibi, including the long-awaited Thunderhouse Falls area, and 3,254 hectares at Northern Peisk Lake in Woodland Caribou, represent genuine conservation gains for two ecologically significant river systems and critical boreal caribou habitat. ORA’s members have paddled these rivers. The Missinaibi River, from Missinaibi Lake through Thunderhouse Falls and onward to the Moose River and James Bay, is one of the most remarkable wilderness canoe routes in Canada. We have a direct and abiding interest in seeing it properly protected.

That said, strong support for this proposal does not preclude pointed observations about its framing, its gaps, and what meaningful protection would actually require. ORA submits the following critique and recommendations in the expectation that this government intends to follow through on both the regulation and the stewardship obligations they imply.

Continue reading →


ERO-025-0908, 0909, 1077: Species Conservation Act, 2025 & Special Economic Zones – Joint

Lake Sturgeon stranded in a hydroelectric facility’s overflow channel.

We, the 87 undersigned organizations, submit the following comments and recommendations on the proposal for developing guidance on section 16 activities under the Species Conservation Act, 2025 (SCA).

We reiterate our objection to the replacement of the Endangered Species Act, 2007 (ESA) with the far weaker SCA as noted in our submission on ERO 025-0380, which was not adequately addressed or responded to when the Government of Ontario proceeded to pass Bill 5. Ontario’s at-risk species need more protections, not less, in the midst of a biodiversity crisis.

Read the submissions here:

ERO-025-0908-Developing guidance on section 16 activities under the Species Conservation Act, 2025
ERO-025-0909-Proposed legislative and regulatory amendments to enable the Species Conservation Act, 2025
ERO-025-1077-Consultation on Proposed Special Economic Zones Criteria


Call for Action on American Eel – Joint

American Eel

Update: Check out The Honourable Joanne Thompson’s 9 March 2026 response below:

Update: Check out DFO’s disappointing News Release here.

American Eel was assessed as threatened by COSEWIC in 2012, with key threats including overharvest, barriers to upstream migration, and death of eels through hydropower turbine strikes. Eel must migrate upstream as elvers and downstream as adults to complete their life cycle. Because of a lack DFO and provincial measures to protect them during their initial mitigation, declining numbers of elvers and young eels reach rearing habitats, and fewer adults survive their spawning journey. Other pressures include the growing international demand for elvers, and the increase of IUU fishing outside of DFO and Indigenous management systems.

Continue reading →


IESO – Long Lead-Time RFP – June 5, 2025

“Canada’s increasing struggle with hydropower is an ill omen representing a wider global problem. Climate change and droughts are threatening hydropower supplies everywhere, and as severe weather events become increasingly common due to climate change, the future of the world’s leading renewable energy source is vulnerable. The greatest problem is not just the severity of any drought but the persistence of drought conditions over an extended period of time. The Yale Climate Connection argues that the link between climate change and increasing drought conditions worldwide is demonstrable, and things are getting worse. Global hydropower generation dropped significantly in the first half of 2023, resulting in an overall increase in fossil-fuel power production to make up for the deficit.”

Continue reading →


How to Truly “Build Canada Strong”

While constitutional change is never easy, the right to a healthy environment is a moral imperative that Canada can no longer afford to ignore—our laws must finally reflect what science and justice demand.

Over 150 countries recognize these environmental rights in law. As the United Nations notes, Canada’s delay is ‘inconsistent with its human rights obligations’[i]—a constitutional gap that perpetuates harm.”

As the UN and Supreme Court affirm environmental rights globally, Canada’s Constitution remains an outlier—a failure we must rectify. From wildfires to poisoned waterways, Canadians are paying the price for this omission. Constitutional change is not optional—it’s survival.

[i] UNEP, Environmental Rule of Law: Global Assessment (Nairobi, 2019), 23. Continue reading →